Skip to main content
Write a Review, Win $500! Help guests by leaving a review of your favorite dishes. Be entered in a drawing to win $500 on 2/1.
Captain Jack's Goodtime Tavern
  • Menu
  • Events
  • Banquets
  • Gallery
  • Merchandise
  • About
  • Contact
Fish FryLob Wrap

Check Out Our

Menu
Menu
Become a VIPGet wings based on your age! Sign up to receive our Wing Special on your next birthday!

Menu

Bayside Baskets

Tom's Tacos (3)

14.59

Plump Cajun shrimp on soft flour tortillas, with shredded lettuce & Pico de Gallo finished with roasted pepper crème

New!
Tom's Tacos (3)
1 review
1 review
 

Chicken Tenders

12.59

Four golden brown chicken fingers with our special fries, served with your choice of dipping sauce

New!
Chicken Tenders
 

Vegan Nuggets

12.59

For that vegetarian, a plant based "chicken" nugget, so good you can't taste the difference, served with French fries

VGNew!
Vegan Nuggets
 

Bayside Starters

Buffalo Cauliflower

10.59

Fresh cauliflower battered and fried to order, tossed in our homemade buffalo sauce, served with a side of blue cheese

New!
Buffalo Cauliflower
2 reviews
2 reviews
 

Pepperoni Bites (8)

10.59

Breaded pockets of spicy pepperoni and mozzarella with a side of marinara for dipping

New!
Pepperoni Bites (8)
1 review
1 review
 

The Best Quesadilla on the Bay

10.59

Stuffed with plenty of cheese, and our house-made Pico De Gallo

With Pulled Chicken +2.40
The Best Quesadilla on the Bay
1 review
1 review
 

Captain Jack's Tuscan Calamari

13.59

Lightly dusted calamari rings and tentacles, topped with olive relish, feta cheese slightly fried and served steaming hot, with marinara for dipping

Captain Jack's Tuscan Calamari
1 review
1 review
 

Boneless Chicken Wings

14.59

3/4 lb. of boneless wings hand-tossed with your choice of Mild, Medium, Hot, Sweet and Tangy, Country Sweet, Honey Hot or Garlic Parmesan served with blue cheese and celery

Boneless Chicken Wings
1 review
1 review
 

Captain Jack's Smothered Nachos

13.59

Tri-colored tortilla chips with seasoned beef, black olives, jalapenos, shredded lettuce, Pico de Gallo. Shredded cheddar and our homemade queso

New!
Captain Jack's Smothered Nachos
 

Battered Mozzarella Planks (6)

9.59

Five battered sticks oozing with mozzarella cheese and served with homemade marinara sauce

Battered Mozzarella Planks (6)
 

Bavarian Pretzel Bites

10.59

A whole bunch of oven baked pretzel nibblers served with a fresh queso sauce for your dipping enjoyment

Bavarian Pretzel Bites
2 reviews
2 reviews
 

Jack's Famous Chicken Wings

13.59

Twelve jumbo Chicken wings hand tossed with your choice of sauce, served with blue cheese and celery

Jack's Famous Chicken Wings
4 reviews
4 reviews
 

Flat Breads

Create Your Own Flat Bread

12.59

With cheese. Choose from any of the toppings listed under the pizza section

Per Additional Topping Each +1.50
New!
 

Buffalo Chicken Flat Bread

13.59

A hand pressed flat bread smothered with medium wing sauce, creamy blue cheese, fresh pulled chicken and cheddar cheese

Buffalo Chicken Flat Bread
 

Chicken Bacon Ranch Flat Bread

14.59

Fresh pulled chicken, crumbled bacon, creamy Ranch dressing and shredded cheddar cheese

Chicken Bacon Ranch Flat Bread
 

Sides

Tater Tots

4.59
 

Onion Rings

4.59
Add Meat Hot Sauce +1.29
 

Cole Slaw

4.59
 

Mike Garlock's Bass Kickin' Beans

4.59
 

Macaroni Salad

4.59
 

Sweet Potato French Fries

4.59
 

Our Own Special Battered French Fries

4.59
1 review
 

Soups & Salads

Garden Salad

Iceberg greens, tomatoes, carrots and croutons served with your choice of dressing

Side 3.99Full 7.99Add 6oz Chicken Breast +5.99Add Sweet and Tangy Marinated Portabellas +4.99
 

Caesar Salad

10.99

The classic romaine lettuce, Caesar dressing, croutons and Asiago cheese

Add Chicken +5.99
 

Jack's Homemade Lobster Bisque

Thick and creamy…you will not be sorry!

Cup 7.99Bowl 9.99
11 pop1 review
 

The Captain's Pizza

Pizza Toppings:
Artichokes, Bacon, Chicken, Banana Peppers, Jalapeno Peppers, Mushrooms, Olives, Onions, Pepperoni, Green Peppers, Pineapple, Roasted Red Peppers, Sausage and Tomatoes

12" Cauliflower Crust and Flat Bread Pizza + $1.50 per topping | Large 16" + $2.00 per topping

Large 16"

18.99
 

Flat Bread Pizza

12.59
 

12" Cauliflower Crust

16.99
GF
 

Captain Jack's Famous Sandwiches

Served with your choice of French Fries, Mac Salad, Tater Tots, Cole Slaw or Potato Chips

Add Ons:
Mild Cheddar, American, Swiss or Creamy Blue Cheese + $1.00

The Frankenweck

14.99

A half-pound of slow roasted prime rib, shaved thin and piled high on our fresh house-made kimmelweck hoagie roll, soaked in our specially seasoned Au Jus and served with a light horseradish cream sauce

New!
3 reviews
 

From the Port to your Belly Wrap

11.99

Our special marinated portabellas, roasted red peppers, artichoke hearts, lettuce, tomato and our garlic basil pesto aioli, all wrapped up in your choice of one of our garlic herb or wheat wraps

New!
 

Buffalo Chicken Wrap

12.99

Our version of Buffalo's specialty, all wrapped up! Fresh marinated pulled chicken, blue cheese, cheddar cheese, lettuce and our special medium wing sauce in a garlic herb or wheat wrap

1 review
 

B.L.T.

10.59

A traditional favorite! Five slices of bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise. Your choice of deli style white or wheat bread or wrap it up in one of our garlic herb or wheat wraps

1 review
 

The Captain's B-52 Bomber

14.59

Shaved beef with peppers, onions and mushrooms served on our house-made hoagie roll and smothered with our homemade queso

New!
2 reviews
 

Roasted Turkey B.L.T

12.59

Shaved turkey topped with bacon, lettuce and tomato with pesto mayonnaise. Your choice of deli style white or wheat, or wrap it up in one of our garlic herb or wheat wraps

Roasted Turkey B.L.T
 

Fish Sandwich

11.59

Half of our famous fresh haddock fish fry served on a roll, beer-battered and fried

Fish Sandwich
 

From Our Grill

All Choices are served on a fresh Brioche roll or Gluten-Free Roll that comes dressed with lettuce, tomato, and pickle. Comes with choice of French Fries, Mac Salad, Tater Tots, Cole Slaw or Potato Chips. 

Choose From our fresh and juicy ½ lb. Angus beef burger, 6oz marinated chicken breasts, Turkey burger or Beyond burger. Then Pick Your Option from Below…

Sweet and Sassy

14.59

Candied bacon, jalapenos, cheddar, and smothered with a ranch barbeque sauce

New!
 

The Plain One

10.59

Plainly delicious! Comes dressed with lettuce and tomato

Add Mild Cheddar, American, Swiss, or Creamy Blue Cheese +1
 

Mushroom Swiss

13.59

Top it with fresh grilled mushrooms and rich melted Swiss cheese

 

Sodus Point "Monster Plate"

14.59

Your choice of a ½ lb. Angus burger with melted American cheese or two of Rochester's finest Zweigle's red hots, along with Mike Garlock's Bass Kickin' beans, mac salad, French fries and our own sweet and spicy meat hot

1 review
 

Wayne County

14.59

Topped with our Memphis barbecue sauce, apple smoked bacon, cheddar cheese and finished with a breaded onion ring

 

The "315er"

11.59

Served open faced and totally smothered with French fries and gravy

 

The Bacon

13.59

Topped with crispy smoked apple wood bacon

Add Mild Cheddar, American, Swiss, or Creamy Blue Cheese +1
 

Dinner Sensations

(AVALIBLE AFTER 4P.M.) 
All dinner selections include two side choices. (Unless otherwise noted) 

Side Choices: French Fries, Tater Tots, Sweet Potato Fries, Mashed Potatoes, Breaded Onion Rings, Baked Potato (after 5:00pm), Macaroni Salad, Cole Slaw, Mike Garlock's Bass Kickin' Beans. 
Add Gravy + $0.89 | Add Meat Hot Sauce + $1.29

Add Ons
Shrimp 6oz + $10.99 | Scallop + $13.99

Chicken French

17.99

Egg dipped chicken, sherry lemon sauce served over mini penne with one side

New!
1 review
 

Seafood Athena

26.99

Colossal shrimp, seared scallop, lump crab, mushrooms, sundried tomatoes, green onions, and mini penne tossed in a sherry Rosa sauce served with one side

New!
 

Broiled Scallops

23.59

Over a half pound of fresh baked steaming jumbo sea scallops, slowly simmered in a lemon herb butter

GF
1 review
 

Jack's Famous Slow Roasted 28 Day Aged Prime Rib

Tender and mouthwatering, our famous Prime Rib, hand rubbed with fresh herbs and spices then slow roasted Available Monday & Saturday

14 oz to 16 oz Cut 23.59Captain's Cut 24 oz 31.59
4 reviews
 

Fish Fry

11-13 ounces of Fresh haddock prepared your way… beer battered, panko breaded, or Broiled with your choice of Old Bay seasoning or Cajun, served with a lemon wedge and homemade tartar sauce

Full Size 16.59Try a Mini 13.59
Fish Fry
8 reviews
8 reviews
 

Jack the Stripper

24.99

14oz of New York's 28 day aged finest cut of beef, seasoned, perfectly marbled and charbroiled to your liking

GF
 

Chicken Castaway

18.59

You will want to reel this one in…two 6 oz. marinated chicken breasts smothered in fire roasted red peppers, marinated portabella mushrooms, artichokes and Swiss cheese

 

Little Pirates

Kids 10 & Under
Includes french fries or apple sauce and 10 oz drink

Hamburger

5.99
 

Chicken Fingers

5.99
 

Grilled Cheese Sandwich

4.99
 

Pepperoni Flat Bread Pizza

6.49
Pepperoni Flat Bread Pizza
 

Cheeseburger

6.49
2 reviews
 

Kraft Macaroni and Cheese

5.29
 

Cheese Flat Bread Pizza

5.99
 

Peanut Butter and Jelly Sandwich

5.89
 

Weekly Dinner Specials

After 5:00 pm

Monday

14.99

Prime Rib Special. Comes with two sides.

 

Thursday

Half price "Select" appetizers 5:00 pm-8:00 pm

Draft specials on most domestic beers

 

Tuesday

13.99

Chicken Parmesan

 
Show All Items
GFGluten-Free
New!New!
VGVegetarian

We cannot guarantee that anything we serve is completely gluten-free. We do not have a gluten-free preparation area.

Customer Pricing Note
All of our menu prices reflect payment with a credit card. If you choose to pay with cash you will receive an immediate discount on our pricing.

Cash Discount
As an incentive for our valued customers, we now provide a 4% immediate discount for those customers who pay with cash. 

Thank you for your buiness.

Made with by Popmenu

Location

Sodus Point, NY8505 Greig St Sodus Point, NY 14555(315) 483-9570
Monday - Sunday: 12:00 pm - 10:00 pm
Bar is open 12:00 PM - Close
Captain Jack's Goodtime Tavern
Website Accessibility Assistance
Opens in a new windowOpens an external siteOpens an external site in a new window